Thursday, January 28, 2021

Queen of Egypt

 Who was the real Cleopatra?

Cleopatra in the famous 1963 movie
One of the most famous of Egyptian queens in history was Cleopatra, who lived during the Roman period in Egypt, just before the birth of Christ. She was the last Ptolemaic ruler of Egypt, meaning she was part of a Greek ruling family and was descended from one of Alexander the Great's generals, who was from  Macedonia in Europe. The Ptolemies were the last dynasty of rulers in Egypt before the Romans and later the Arabs controlled the country. Throughout history this last Egyptian queen was considered to have been very beautiful and was therefore able to form relationships with the great Roman Generals Mark Anthony and Julius Caesar. A new movie will soon be coming out about Cleopatra and there is an internet controversy over the choice of Gal Godot, a White, Jewish actress from Israel, who was also in the recent Wonder Woman movies. Some people claim that the actress should be a Black African actress or Arab because the identity of Cleopatra's mother was possibly uncertain and she may have been black or brown in skin color. Her father was certainly Greek and was the Ptolemaic king of Egypt, so he was therefore a White person. But some people claim that since Cleopatra's mother was not necessarily the Ptolemaic, Greek queen, perhaps she was not herself (completely) White.

A Roman painting of Cleopatra

However, most scholars who study ancient history state that Cleopatra's mother was a in fact a Ptolemaic queen, also of Greek origin. Furthermore, in ancient Egypt the native population was more closely related to the populations of the Middle East and Southern Europe rather than to Sub-Saharan Africa. (Schuenemann, V., Peltzer, A., Welte, B. et al. Ancient Egyptian mummy genomes suggest an increase of Sub-Saharan African ancestry in post-Roman periods. Nat Commun 8, 15694 (2017). This means even if Cleopatra's mother was Egyptian, Cleopatra herself would not have been black or brown, but partly Middle Eastern as well as partly Greek in ancestry, and therefore basically similar to modern Israelis, which may make Gal Gadot a good choice for the role.

Alexander the Great
It is important to remember that Africa is a very large continent with different regions and different peoples. In North Africa, the native people are different from the people in Sub-Saharan Africa. Sub-Saharan means south of the great Sahara desert, the largest desert in the world. In Sub-Sharan Africa the people are basically dark in skin color, like many African Americans. African-Americans are  descended from people that were brought from western Sub-Saharan Africa, from places such as Ghana and Nigeria. However, the peoples of North African countries like Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and Egypt are different, and are more similar to Middle Easterners and Southern Europeans. 
 
The Nubian pyramids of Meroe
There were ancient civilizations in Sub-Saharan Africa as well, such as Songhai, Aksum, Ghana and  Benin, and these societies were composed of Black Africans. So was the area of Nubia, south of Egypt in what is today Sudan. Nubians adopted Egyptian culture and created tombs and buildings like those in Egypt further north along the Nile river. 
 
Perhaps It is a waste of time to argue over the 'race' of historical figures like Cleopatra. Each group of people has their own history and ancestry and everyone should be proud of their own background and value their own identity.

Question: Who do you think should play Cleopatra?

Gal Gadot defends her casting as Cleopatra after director was accused of 'whitewashing' 

Greek or Arab? Race Controversy Erupts Over White Actress Portraying Cleopatra

Gal Gadot Defends Playing Cleopatra After 'Whitewashing' Controversy: 'Anybody Can Make This Movie' 

Gal Gadot as Cleopatra is a backwards step for Hollywood representation

Was Cleopatra White? After Controversial Gal Gadot Casting, Experts Weigh In

Ancient Egyptian mummy genomes suggest an increase of Sub-Saharan African ancestry in post-Roman periods 

Roman statue of Cleopatra

Gal Gadot and Roman statue of Cleopatra

Roman portrait of Cleopatra
 
Modern Egyptian Women at a demonstration against the government





No comments:

Post a Comment

An end and a beginning

 The Covid 19 pandemic: where we've been and where we are going! A year ago on March 11, 2020, the Covid 19 virus had effected enough co...